Scaling with Soul — 5 Branding Lessons for Family Businesses from Caroline's Cakes' Richard Reutter

June 5, 2024

Richard Reutter's story is a testament to the power of passion, perseverance, and staying true to your roots. As the President of Caroline's Cakes, the mail-order bakery founded by his late mother Caroline Reutter, Richard has helped grow the business from a home-based passion project to a thriving national brand. But through all the growth and changes, Richard has remained committed to preserving the authentic family recipes, homemade quality, and warm personal touch that define the Caroline's Cakes brand.

In this episode of The Marketing Factor, Richard shares his insights on building an authentic brand that connects with customers on a deep emotional level. From seizing big opportunities before you feel ready to creating immersive brand experiences that go beyond just selling products, Richard's stories offer valuable lessons for entrepreneurs looking to scale with soul. Through it all, a common thread emerges: the importance of infusing genuine passion, heart, and storytelling into every aspect of your brand. Richard's experiences illustrate how even the smallest family business can create an outsized impact by staying true to its core values and never losing sight of the human touch.

Dive into the full episode with Richard Reutter here:

If you don't have time to listen, here are the top five takeaways from our conversation:

1. The power of passion and drive in building a brand from the ground up

When it comes to building a successful brand, genuine passion and drive can make all the difference. As Richard Reutter, President of Caroline's Cakes, shared about his mother and company founder Caroline Reutter:

"[My mother was] magnetic, passionate and driven. Those characteristics are genuine - she wasn't faking it. She had the drive, she led from the front and boy, could she motivate people."

Caroline's passion and tireless drive were instrumental in taking Caroline's Cakes from a home-based side hustle to a thriving mail-order business. Her magnetic personality and motivation skills rallied the team to put in the long hours needed, especially in the early days.

2. Saying yes to opportunities, even when you're not fully ready

Sometimes, the key to growth is being bold enough to say yes to a big opportunity, even if you're not entirely sure how you'll pull it off. Richard recounted a pivotal moment in Caroline's Cakes' history:

"She knew her opportunity when it was in front of her and she jumped. Now it's in the year 2000. She had done the cakes as a hobby, eight cakes a day for close to 20 years. And when she got that phone call [for 2000 cakes]... That was when it was real. In my mind, that's when Caroline's Cakes, the business, was officially born."

When Caroline got a huge 2000 cake order despite only making 8 cakes a day at that point, she didn't hesitate to say yes and figure out the details later. Recognizing and seizing growth opportunities, even if you're not quite ready, can be the catalyst that takes a small business to the next level.

3. Preserving authenticity and quality as you scale

As a business grows, it can be tempting to cut corners to increase efficiency and profits. But Richard believes staying true to Caroline's Cakes' original recipes and quality standards has been crucial to their success:

"Very little about our cake recipes has changed. As we've grown and developed, we focused on areas like improving our packaging and the overall customer experience. But the authenticity of those recipes has not changed since our founding."

While Caroline's Cakes has innovated in areas like packaging and customer experience, compromising on the cakes' authentic homemade taste and quality to scale faster has never been an option. Preserving what makes your product special is central to long-term brand loyalty.

4. Connecting with customers through brand storytelling

In today's crowded market, customers crave authentic brands they can relate to on a personal level. For Richard, sharing his mother's inspiring journey is just as important as selling cakes:

"I want to sell the story as much as I want to sell the product... It's very personal to me to continue to tell her story, which is an authentic one and I think is deserving of being told."

By weaving Caroline's story into every touchpoint, from childhood photos in the bakery to handwritten notes, Richard helps customers connect emotionally with the brand.

5. Creating a memorable and immersive brand experience

Brick-and-mortar retail may seem archaic for an e-commerce brand, but Richard has found that their Spartanburg storefront has elevated the Caroline's Cakes brand experience:

"You can come in, have a glass of champagne and a couple of cake bites. You can try three or four different slices of cake instead of feeling like you have to have the whole cake on its own. We have a lot of stuff from brands that we're really good friends with that we're able to showcase, bring other brands that we admire and pair well with our products so we can create the whole experience here."

The storefront immerses customers in the Caroline's Cakes brand, engaging multiple senses and creating special moments that can't be replicated online. By going beyond just selling products to crafting memorable experiences, small businesses can foster deeper brand connections and loyalty.

Helping the next generation of great businesses grow online.

We thread the needle of good design, purposeful content and performance focus through of digital advertising, email marketing, and website optimization.
Learn More
© 2024 Cobble Hill